Extra ripe bananas are a convenient snack, but how do they compare with less-ripe fruit when it comes to blood sugar? In this post we’ll explore the difference in glucose response and share tips for enjoying bananas while maintaining steady energy.
Nutrition Snapshot (1 medium ripe banana)
- Calories: ~110
- Carbohydrates: 28 g total, including about 15 g natural sugars and 3 g dietary fiber.
- Key micronutrients: 450 mg potassium, along with vitamin B6, vitamin C and magnesium.
Glucose Response Snapshot
| Banana ripeness | Spike (mg/dL) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Extra ripe banana | ~35 mg/dL rise | Overripe bananas have a glycemic index around 57 (medium) and a glycemic load around 9. |
| Ripe banana | ~30 mg/dL rise | Ripe bananas still have a low GI around 51 with a moderate GL of 13. |
| Green (unripe) banana | ~20 mg/dL rise | Unripe bananas have a lower GI of 42 and GL of 11 because they contain more resistant starch. |
Why Extra Ripe Bananas Spike More
- More sugar, less resistant starch: As a banana ripens, enzymes break down complex starches into simple sugars. Overripe bananas therefore have more sugar and a higher glycemic index than unripe fruit.
- Moderate glycemic load: Even though the GI increases, a medium extra-ripe banana still has a moderate glycemic load of about 9, so it won’t spike blood sugar as quickly as candy or soda.
- Fiber still counts: Bananas contain soluble fiber and pectin, which help slow digestion and may improve satiety.
Health Benefits
- Nutrient dense: Bananas provide potassium, magnesium and vitamin C, which support heart and muscle function.
- Prebiotic resistant starch: Slightly unripe bananas contain resistant starch that feeds beneficial gut bacteria and may improve insulin sensitivity.
- Convenient energy: Natural sugars and electrolytes make bananas a good pre- or post-workout snack, especially when paired with protein.
Potential Downsides
- Higher sugar content: Extra ripe bananas have more free sugars; eating several at once could elevate blood sugar and may not fit low-carb diets.
- Portion size matters: Even though their GI is moderate, a large banana has about 28 g carbohydrates; stick to a small to medium fruit.
- Pairing helps: Combine banana with nut butter, yogurt or seeds to add fat and protein for a slower glucose rise.
Tips for Enjoying Bananas
- Choose slightly under-ripe bananas if you are sensitive to sugar spikes; they contain more resistant starch and less sugar.
- Eat one banana at a time and pair with protein or healthy fat (for example, peanut butter or Greek yogurt).
- Use extra ripe bananas in baking rather than eating them alone; the fiber and fat in baked goods can blunt the sugar impact.
Bottom Line
Bananas—whether green, yellow or spotted brown—are nutritious fruits. Extra ripe bananas are sweeter and may spike blood sugar slightly more than less ripe ones, but their moderate glycemic load and fiber mean they’re still a healthier choice than processed sweets. Pair them with protein or healthy fat and enjoy in moderation.
Forever Health 
Leave a comment